What is seeing? The invisible enemy of astrophotography
The night is clear, not a cloud in the sky, the mount tracks smoothly. And yet: the stars quiver, planetary detail smears, the image looks as if someone held cling film in front of the eyepiece. Welcome to the club. The culprit is so-called seeing.
Seeing describes the turbulence of Earth's atmosphere and its effect on starlight. Air is not a homogeneous medium but a constantly moving mixture of layers of different temperature and density. Every time light from a star falls through these turbulent layers it is refracted, deflected and distorted. In the eyepiece the result looks like shimmering, dancing star discs.
Why do stars twinkle but planets do not?
A good question that every non-astronomer will ask as soon as you bring up the topic. Stars twinkle because they are so far away that even in the largest telescope they appear as point-like light sources. A single ray of light, sent through turbulent air, dances merrily back and forth.
Planets, on the other hand, have a measurable disc. The light arrives from many slightly different angles at once, and the disturbances partly average out. That is why planets twinkle less, even though they shine through the very same atmosphere. Under poor seeing they still suffer, though: detail smears, the belt structures on Jupiter turn soft, Saturn's rings lose their sharpness.
How is seeing measured?
The most common unit is the arcsecond ("). It describes the apparent diameter of a star's blur disc caused by atmospheric turbulence. The smaller the value, the better the seeing.
Professional observatories at good sites such as Paranal in Chile regularly reach values below 0.5 arcseconds. In Central Europe 1 to 2 arcseconds is a realistic average, on good nights sometimes less. Values above 3 arcseconds turn planetary imaging into a test of patience.
What influences seeing?
Seeing arises wherever air masses of different temperature meet. This happens on several levels:
Local seeing
The most common and at the same time most easily influenced factor. Asphalt, rooftops and concrete slabs store heat during the day and release it at night. The rising warm air right above the observing site causes local turbulence. Anyone observing from a roof terrace is fighting their own building. Meadows, fields and forest clearings are therefore much better suited than courtyards or car parks.
Ground-level seeing
The near-ground air layer up to a few hundred metres can also be turbulent, especially when air warmed during the day cools and sinks in the evening. This effect is typical of sunny summer days, on which the night brings poor seeing despite a clear sky.
Jet stream
At 8 to 12 kilometres altitude the jet stream races through the atmosphere at up to 300 km/h. When it runs directly above the observing site it causes strong turbulence and poor seeing, even in completely clear and calm weather at the ground. If the jet stream is far away, seeing can be exceptionally good.
Seeing in SkyGrade
SkyGrade obtains seeing data from the service 7Timer, which evaluates atmospheric models and provides forecasts for astronomical seeing. The value feeds directly into the deep-sky score and the planetary score.
For deep-sky objects such as galaxies and nebulae, seeing is less critical than for planetary imaging, because these objects are extended sources. Cloud cover and transparency matter more there. For planetary imaging, on the other hand, seeing is often the single most important factor, deciding between crisp detail and mushy discs.
Practical tips
- Observe from meadows or in nature if possible, not on terraces or paved surfaces
- Let your telescope acclimatise for at least 30 to 60 minutes before observing, so the optics reach ambient temperature
- Planetary imaging benefits most from good seeing, deep-sky imaging somewhat less
- Check the jet stream: if it is not over your region, chances of good seeing are good
- Summer nights often have worse seeing than winter nights, but the nights are shorter and warmer
Further reading
- Transparency: why a cloudless sky can still be poor – the second big air factor, often opposite to seeing.
- The Bortle scale: how dark is your sky really? – besides seeing, light pollution is the second big factor for good conditions.
- Astronomical twilight: when does real night begin? – good seeing is useless if you observe at the wrong time.